Welcome back Catherine! Each line of your tone scale got better and better! With the larger boxes on the top. The middle box could be a little lighter, but first I would make the darkest box even darker. It is not as dark as you achieved in the lines below and it would affect what needed to be done with the middle box. With the second line I do not see much difference between #6,7,8 or 9, but you are almost there with line 3. I would lighten the #2 box on both lines and work on tweaking the boxes so there is a distinct progression. Good job!
Welcome back Catherine! Each line of your tone scale got better and better! With the larger boxes on the top. The middle box could be a little lighter, but first I would make the darkest box even darker. It is not as dark as you achieved in the lines below and it would affect what needed to be done with the middle box. With the second line I do not see much difference between #6,7,8 or 9, but you are almost there with line 3. I would lighten the #2 box on both lines and work on tweaking the boxes so there is a distinct progression. Good job!